The short answer
Use Shopify Subscriptions if you sell a simple subscribe-and-save offer: it is free, bills weekly, monthly or yearly, retries failed payments, and lets customers skip, pause and cancel. Choose Recharge when you need what the free app leaves out, such as customers swapping products themselves, cancellation and win-back flows, upsells or bundles, and the cost works for you: $149 a month plus 1.50% + 20¢ per transaction on Starter, or $499 a month plus 1.25% + 20¢ on Scale, which is the plan with bundles. Decide on two questions: which of those features you would use, and what the percentage comes to at your order volume.
Recharge vs Shopify Subscriptions, side by side
| Feature | Recharge | Shopify Subscriptions |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly price | Starter $149 after a 60-day free trial; Scale $499; Custom by contract | Free |
| Transaction fee | 1.50% + 20¢ per transaction on Starter; 1.25% + 20¢ on Scale | None from the app |
| Developer and App Store rating (13 Nov 2026) | Recharge; 4.8 from 3,159 reviews | Shopify; 3.8 from 904 reviews |
| Checkout | Shopify Checkout, through Recharge's Shopify Checkout Integration | Shopify Checkout; plans and contracts are managed in the Shopify admin |
| What customers can change themselves | Skip, add and swap products, reschedule deliveries | Skip, pause, resume, cancel, payment method, shipping address |
| Failed payments | Failed Payment Recovery with smart retries and payment-update prompts, on every plan | You set the number of retries and the days between them, then skip, pause or cancel |
| Cancellation and win-back | Smart Cancellation Prevention and win-back offers, on every plan | Customers cancel from their account; the app's documentation lists no save or win-back flow |
| Bundles and boxes | Preset and build-your-own bundles on Scale and Custom, not on Starter | Not compatible with bundles |
| Reporting | Revenue, retention and churn analytics with industry benchmarks | Subscription revenue and new, active and canceled subscriptions |
| Moving subscribers in | Self-service CSV migration tool; end-to-end migration support on Scale | CSV import of contracts from Shopify Checkout-integrated apps |
Read from each company's published pages on ; the pages are listed under Sources.
What Shopify Subscriptions does for free, and where it stops
Shopify Subscriptions is listed as free on the Shopify App Store and is managed from the Shopify admin. Shopify's Help Center says a plan can renew weekly, monthly or yearly, carry a percentage, amount-off or fixed-price discount, bill on a specific day or date, and end by itself after a set number of orders, from 2 to 1,000. Shopify also describes a pre-paid model, where the customer makes one advance payment for a set number of months. Subscription products can be sold on the online store, Shopify POS, Shop and custom storefronts.
Customers manage the subscription from their customer account. They can skip an upcoming order, pause, resume or cancel, change or add a payment method, and edit the shipping address, and the app emails them 3 days before each recurring charge. When a payment fails, you choose how many times the app retries, how many days apart, and whether the subscription is skipped, paused or cancelled once the retries run out. The customer is notified in each case.
The limits are just as specific:
- Bundles. Shopify's considerations page says bundles aren't compatible with the Shopify Subscriptions app.
- Customer self-service. Changing the products, the quantity or the delivery frequency, and rescheduling an order, are documented as things the merchant does in the admin, not actions in the customer account.
- Reporting. The app shows four metrics: subscription revenue and new, active and canceled subscriptions, compared against the previous 7, 30 or 90 days.
- Retention. The Help Center pages for the app describe no cancellation offers, win-back campaigns or upsells.
What Recharge adds, plan by plan
Recharge's pricing page lists these on every plan, including Starter: a no-code customer portal where subscribers add and swap products and reschedule deliveries, Smart Cancellation Prevention, Failed Payment Recovery, win-back offers, upsell and cross-sell at checkout, after purchase and in the cart, automated workflows, prepaid subscriptions, and analytics with industry benchmarks.
Scale adds preset and build-your-own bundles, tiered discounts, Surprise and delight gifting, subscriber journey A/B testing, the JavaScript SDK and Storefront API, hands-on implementation and end-to-end migration support. It also adds Concierge SMS, which is billed per message segment at $0.03 in the US and Canada and $0.06 internationally. Loyalty, which covers credits, tiers and referrals, is an add-on billed as a separate line on the invoice.
The detail that matters most against the free app is the bundle tier. If bundles are the reason you are leaving Shopify Subscriptions, Recharge Starter does not include them. They start on Scale, at $499 a month before transaction fees.
What Recharge costs next to a free app
Recharge charges twice: a monthly plan fee, and a percentage plus 20¢ on every transaction it processes. Starter is month-to-month with a 60-day free trial that carries no transaction fees, so the first two months understate the cost. Scale is sold through Recharge's sales team. The table works both plans through at four order volumes; Shopify Subscriptions is $0 in every row because the app has no fee.
The plan fee is the smaller part as a store grows. At 100 orders a month it is $149 of Starter's $229. At 2,500 orders it is $149 of $2,149, and the other $2,000 is transaction fees. Scale costs more than Starter in every row: at the published rates the two only break even at $140,000 a month in processed revenue, which is 3,500 orders at $40.
Recharge's help centre says the fee is calculated on the total processed amount, including shipping, taxes and refunded orders, and that it applies to one-time orders Recharge processes as well as recurring ones.
| Subscription orders a month | Processed a month | Shopify Subscriptions | Recharge Starter | Recharge Scale |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 100 | $4,000 | $0 | $229 | $569 |
| 500 | $20,000 | $0 | $549 | $849 |
| 1,000 | $40,000 | $0 | $949 | $1,199 |
| 2,500 | $100,000 | $0 | $2,149 | $2,249 |
Assumes one order per subscriber per month at $40, including shipping and tax. Recharge cost is the plan fee, plus the percentage of the processed amount, plus 20¢ per order: Starter at $149 and 1.50%, Scale at $499 and 1.25%. Recharge says Scale rates scale with volume but does not publish the steps. The 60-day trial is not counted. Payment processing from Shopify Payments or another gateway applies with either app and is not included.
Do both run on Shopify's checkout?
Yes, for a store installing either app today. Shopify Subscriptions is Shopify's own app: a purchase creates a subscription contract that you manage in the Shopify admin, the customer's payment details are stored by Shopify, and the store must use Shopify Payments, PayPal Express, Authorize.net, Adyen or, for select merchants, Stripe.
Recharge connects through what it calls the Shopify Checkout Integration, which applies to Shopify stores that installed Recharge after 2 November 2020. Its help centre says the integration uses Shopify's Subscription APIs to create and process subscriptions directly through the Shopify Checkout, with subscription management in Recharge and order processing through Shopify. The pricing page lists a unified checkout on Shopify on every plan. Recharge's older, separate Recharge Checkout on Shopify is deprecated, and a store still on it has to convert before it can take new checkout orders.
So the checkout is not what separates the two. The difference is the tooling on top of it, and that Recharge adds its own fee to each order while the free app does not.
Moving from Shopify Subscriptions to Recharge later
Starting on the free app does not lock you in, but the move is a project. Shopify Subscriptions exports its contracts to a CSV file. Recharge has a self-service migration tool for stores coming from other Shopify subscription apps, which imports a CSV in Recharge's own template, 5,000 rows at a time. Recharge's guide says it supports the migration but not the data formatting, so reshaping the export into that template is your work or an agency's. End-to-end migration support is a Scale feature.
Two things do not come across. Recharge says historical data and analytics are not migrated, and migrated customers show as new customers on the migration date. For payment methods already stored in Shopify, Recharge recommends including the Shopify payment method ID in the file; without it, Recharge uses the customer's most recently created valid payment method, which can be the wrong one.
Leave the uninstall for last. Shopify's Help Center says that uninstalling Shopify Subscriptions deletes the plans and contracts created in it, along with any discounts that use it. Recharge's guide has you go live on Recharge first and migrate second, so export, import and audit the data in Recharge before you remove the free app.
Which one to pick
Pick Recharge if
- Customers keep asking you to swap a product, add an item or move a delivery, and you want them to do it themselves in a portal.
- You would use cancellation flows, win-back offers and upsells, and want them from one vendor.
- You sell bundles or build-your-own boxes on subscription and can budget for Scale at $499 a month plus fees.
- The fee works at your volume. On Starter it is about $549 a month at 500 orders of $40.
Pick Shopify Subscriptions if
- You sell one or a few products on a simple weekly, monthly or yearly schedule.
- Skip, pause, resume and cancel are enough self-service for your customers.
- You are still finding out whether subscriptions work for your store and do not want a monthly bill while you do.
- You do not sell bundles, which Shopify says are not compatible with the app.
A third option between the two: Curobi
Curobi is our app, so read this section as a vendor describing its own product. It sits between the two. It is built on the same Shopify-native Subscription Contracts and checkout as the free app, and adds customer-side editing, failed-payment recovery, bundles and boxes for a flat price with 0% transaction fees. It is free for up to 50 active subscriptions, and paid plans cost $9.99 to $69.99 every 30 days whatever your order volume.
It does not match Recharge feature for feature. Curobi has no SMS flows, no A/B testing and no enterprise tooling. If those are why you are looking at Recharge, Recharge is the better fit.
| Price | Free up to 50 active subscriptions; paid plans $9.99 to $69.99 per 30 days, flat |
|---|---|
| Transaction fees | 0% on every plan |
| Customer portal | Skip, pause and cancel on every plan; quantity, swap and reschedule from Starter ($9.99) |
| Bundles and boxes | Mix & Match bundles on Business ($29.99); curated and build-your-own boxes on Pro ($69.99) |
| Moving from Recharge | CSV import on Business and up |
Curobi pricingWhat Curobi doesCurobi on the Shopify App Store
Questions merchants ask
Is Shopify Subscriptions free?
Yes. The Shopify App Store lists Shopify Subscriptions as free, with no monthly fee and no per-order fee from the app. You still pay your usual payment processing fees on each subscription order, and Shopify's Help Center notes that third-party transaction fees are charged if Shopify Payments isn't activated on your store.
Is Recharge better than Shopify Subscriptions?
Recharge does more; whether that makes it better depends on what you would use. Every Recharge plan includes a portal where customers swap products and reschedule deliveries, cancellation prevention, failed payment recovery, win-back and upsell tools, and Scale adds bundles, tiered discounts and SMS. Shopify Subscriptions covers recurring billing, discounts, skip, pause, cancel and failed-payment retries at no cost. If that list covers your program, Recharge's $149 a month plus 1.50% + 20¢ per transaction pays for features you would not use.
Does Recharge charge transaction fees on top of Shopify's payment fees?
Yes. Recharge says its pricing is separate from any fees charged by your ecommerce platform or payment processor, so its 1.50% + 20¢ per transaction on Starter, or 1.25% + 20¢ on Scale, is added to what Shopify Payments or another gateway charges (Recharge's pricing page and help centre, checked 13 November 2026). The fee is calculated on the total processed amount, including shipping, taxes and refunded orders. At 500 subscription orders a month of $40 each, Recharge comes to about $549 a month on Starter and $849 on Scale, while Shopify Subscriptions has no app fee.
Can I switch from Shopify Subscriptions to Recharge later?
Yes. Shopify Subscriptions exports its contracts to a CSV file, and Recharge has a self-service migration tool that imports subscribers from other Shopify subscription apps in its own CSV template, 5,000 rows at a time, so the export has to be reformatted first. Recharge does not migrate order history or analytics, and migrated customers show as new on the migration date. Check the import before you uninstall Shopify Subscriptions, because Shopify deletes the app's plans, contracts and subscription discounts when it is removed.
Is there an option between Shopify Subscriptions and Recharge?
Yes. Curobi, which publishes this page, is one. It runs on the same Shopify Subscription Contracts and checkout as the free app, is free for up to 50 active subscriptions, and then costs a flat $9.99 to $69.99 every 30 days with 0% transaction fees. Customers can change quantity, swap products and reschedule from the $9.99 plan, Mix & Match bundles are on the $29.99 plan, and curated and build-your-own boxes are on the $69.99 plan. It has no SMS flows or A/B testing, which Recharge does.
Sources
Every price and capability above was read from these pages on 13 November 2026. Vendors change both, so check the page before you decide.
- Shopify App Store: Shopify Subscriptions
- Shopify Help Center: Shopify Subscriptions
- Shopify Help Center: Shopify Subscriptions app eligibility considerations
- Shopify Help Center: Create and edit subscription plans
- Shopify Help Center: Managing subscription contracts
- Shopify Help Center: Shopify Subscriptions customer experience
- Shopify Help Center: Managing Shopify Subscriptions app settings
- Shopify Help Center: Shopify Subscriptions analytics overview
- Shopify Help Center: Importing and exporting a contract CSV
- Shopify Help Center: Subscription billing models
- Recharge: Pricing
- Shopify App Store: Recharge Subscriptions App
- Recharge Help Center: Recharge billing and pricing
- Recharge Help Center: Shopify Checkout Integration overview
- Recharge Help Center: Identifying your store's Recharge checkout platform
- Recharge Help Center: Migrating to Recharge
- Recharge Help Center: Migrate from another subscription app to Recharge
